I didn't hear it until 2012, even though it came out late in 2011, but the Black Keys' El Camino is really good. It's no Rubber Factory or Brothers, but it has tons or replay value.
I still have not gotten GbV's Let's Go Eat the Factory because I was sort of let down by the few times I played the preview of the album on NPR's website. I'm hoping to wait a while and re-discover it, hopefully to a better reception. I'm so bummed out by this.