Since you are into fishing NoahFex, have you considered Eagle River or Minocqua Wisconsin? We rented some cabins for my friend Tim's bachelor party. Most places rent boats too. Plus both downtown's have a lively bar scene in the warmer months. I'd give the edge to Minocqua because they have the Minocqua Brewing Company and Ottos, two of my favorite bars. You have Lake of the Torches casino nearby, strip clubs if it ends up going in that direction (there are two in Eagle River), fishing, and just lounging around drinking beer.