This should be cool. I just finished the book and I loved it.
*SPOILERS*
Points of implausibility:
-"Dork" gets regular blow jobs from hot girls. Yes, there was an explanation of sorts for this behavior, but seriously? We're supposed to feel bad for the guy? I would except for, oh yeah, I still remember what high school was like for actual dorks. And it didn't involve blow jobs, hand jobs, or any other kind of jobs (Except maybe Steve Jobs! am i rite?).
-Two guys are music nerds in the 2000s but only listen to music pre1975 or so. Even the biggest music dorks in high school (me, etc) listened to at least some newer stuff, if for no other reason than to mock it. On one hand, this was kind of a betrayal of the author's own high school experience. On the other hand, I suppose it would have ruined it if Frank had tried to listen to the radio for a few hours a day just to be able to make up-to-date music references. That would have inevitably failed. And sticking to the early to classic period makes it a little more timeless, I suppose.
-The ambiguous ending was okay, but a little unsatisfying. (Disclaimer: I think most novels don't end particularly well.)
Despite these relatively minor points, I loved the book. Some passages in particular were quite excellent. One short passage comes to mind--where the main character makes fun of his step-dad (which is only human) and then feels bad about it (which is only human) and then makes a comment about being human being an excuse for a lot of things, and being human sort of sucks. Or something. Obviously I'm slaughtering it, but it was one of a number of excellent short passages.
I thought the band names were great (and familiar, I remember doing stuff just like that all day throughout high school) and the plot was good. It was second to the characters, but good enough to drive the story along. I particularly liked the sound equipment set-up. I used a Karaoke machine with a piece of crap guitar and a RadioShack $10 mic plugged in to it.
Long live Frank Portman (remember the minor scandal when that human rights comp came out and they put his full name in the liner notes?). That's great that his next book is already sold. I'm glad something good ended up coming out of the east bay. I hope this doesn't mean the end of MTX, but if it does, at least it ended for something worthwhile.